Home / News / Big Ben chimes for Taxpayer in NSW Court of Appeal

Big Ben chimes for Taxpayer in NSW Court of Appeal

The NSW Court of Appeal has found in favour of the taxpayer (Big Ben Holdings Pty Ltd) in its claim for exemption from transfer duty on a $10 million intra-corporate group acquisition of interests in land ([2026] NSWCA 250).

Chris Peadon of New Chambers, leading Christopher Hartcher of University Chambers, acted for the taxpayer both at trial and on the appeal, instructed by Mr Tony Wassaf and Ms Maria Yiasemides of Jones Day.

The reason the Commissioner assessed the taxpayer on the intra-group transfer was that it occurred under a single Contract for Sale pursuant to which the taxpayer also acquired interests in the same land of non-related entities.  The sale was effected in this manner so that the acquisition would be treated as a GST-free supply of a “going concern”.

The Commissioner contended that this constituted a single “dutiable transaction” and the exempting provision for intra-group corporate reconstruction transactions (s. 273B) therefore did not apply.

The Court of Appeal (Ward P, Ball and Free JJA) agreed with the Trial Judge (Justice Hmelnitsky) that the interests in land held by each vendor as tenant in common was a separate item of property and a separate item of “dutiable property”.  It followed that the intra-group transfer was a separate “dutiable transaction” and that in the circumstances the exemption applied.

Chris Peadon specialises in complex tax advisory and disputes work.  He is ranked Band 1 for tax work in the Chambers & Partners client survey.

Please contact the Clerk for enquiries about his availability.

Back to all

Latest News

View all news
Secret Link